Anveshi - Research Centre for Women's Studies

  • Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size

Newsletter October 2008

 

In  the  footsteps  of  Ayyankali

by P.  Mary  Kumari  (Madiga)

Translated  from  Telugu  original  by  D.  Vasanta

Kerala,  the  state  with  the  highest  literacy  rate  is  also  the  land  of  several  social  reformers  who  led  many  social  movements  and  brough  about  significant  changes  in  that  society.  Ayyankali  (1863‐1941)  was  one  of  them.  He  was  the  contemporary  of  Raja  Ram  Mohan  Roy,  Ramakrishna  Paramahamsa,  Dayananda  Saraswathi,  and  Vivekananda.  While  we  have  access  to  histories  of  some  of  these  social  reformers,  Ayyankali’s  ideas  and  actions  remained  hidden  from  mainstream  history.  However,  just  as  one  cannot  hide  the  luminescence  generated  by  fireflies,  no  one  can  really  bury  the  struggles  waged  by  an  untouchable.  The  more  one  tries  to  hide  it,  the  more  luminescent  it  becomes.  In  this  sense,  Ayyankali  is  different  from  the  other  social  reformers  that  we  have  heard  of.  As  early  as  1905,  he  established  Sadhu  Jana  Paripalana  Sangham an  organization through  which  he  sought  social  justice  and  human  rights  for  his  pople.  Most  social  reformers  who  participate  in  peoples’  movements  are  usually  literate,  but  not  Ayyankali.  He  was  not  only  illiterate  but  also  belonged  to  the  untouchable  caste.  The  others  who  waged  struggled  for  obtaining  access  to  education  for  the  untouchables  in  his  times  were:  Jotiba  Phule,  Savithri  Bai,  Narayan  Guru,  and  Dr.  B.  R.  Ambedkar.  Even  these  leaders  educated  themselves  before  fighting  for  educational  rights  for  others.  Ayyankali,  much  before  them,  specifically,  towards  the  end  of  19th century  and  early  20th century,  waged  a  ‘war’  in  Kerala  for  educational  opportunities  for  all.

Ayyankali  fought  against  the  practice  of  untouchability  and  demanded  self‐respect  particularly  on  behalf  of  women.  He  presided  over  peoples’  courts;  ran  a  magazine  in  support  of  his  organization  (Sadhu  Jana  Paripalana  Sangham);  argued  for  provision  for  temple  entry  by  people  of  his  community…generally  opposed  all  kinds  of  Hindu  Brahminical  values.  He  spilt  his  own  blood  to  pave  way  for  the  untouchables  to  have  the  right  to  travel  on  the  main  roads  and  highways.

Ayyankali  was  one  of  seven  children  born  on  August  28,  1863  to  a  couple  belonging  to  an  untouchable  caste  (Puliyan)  in  a  village  called  Venganur,  part  of  the  then  Trivandrum  presidency.   Born  long  before  all  the  Bahujan  leaders  of  this  country  Ayyankali  created  a  social  revolution  despite  his  lack  of  literacy  ad  low  social  status.

As  a  mark  of  respect  to  this  great  leader  of  the  downtrodden,  the  Govt.  of  Kerala  ensured  that  Ayyankali’s  mammoth  stone  statue  was  installed  in  the  city  of  Trivandrum  by  the  then  Prime  Minister,  Indira  Gandhi.  I  think  it  is  essential  for  those  who  are  involved  and  /  or  interested  in  social  movements  to  study  Ayyankali’s  history.  He  could  not  receive  any  education  because  during  his  childhood,  untouchables  were  not  allowed  to  enter  schools.  However,  he  was  determined  to  see  that  education  becomes  available  to  people  of  future  generations  in  his  community  and  to  achieve  thatgoal,  he  worked  hard  all  his  life.

In  the  year  1904  when  Government  schools  denied  admission  to  untouchables,  he  sold  his  own  plot  of  land  (on  which  he  was  to  build  a  house)  and  established  a  school  in  its  place.  Children  used  sand  to  write  on,  for  there  were  no  blackboards;  their  fingers  became  pencils.  But  the  upper  castes  couldn’t  bear  all  this.  They  destroyed  Ayyankali’s  school.  No  one  came  forward  to  work  as  a  teacher  in  that  school  even  though  Ayyankali  was  prepared  to  pay  Rs.  9/‐ as  salary.  At  last,  Parameshwaran  Pillai,  considered  a  mental  patient  among  the  upper  castes  came  forward  to  work,  but  the  Brahmins  and  his  fellow  men  threatened  to  kill  him.  Ayyankali  had  to  appoint  a  bodyguard  to  protect  Pillai.  He  himself  watched  over  Pillai  and  ensured  that  classes  went  on  without  any  disruption.  Eventually,  he  managed  to  open  up  schools  in  other  villages  and  continue  his  struggle  for  education.

Even  before  the  birth  of  the  Communist  Party  in  our  country,  in  the  year  1907,  Ayyankali  organized  the  working  class  people.  He  held  the  very  first  strike  by  daily‐wage  labourers  and  created  history.  When  the  Travencore  Maharaja  refused  permission  for  that  meeting,  he  held  it  in  the  backwaters  of  Kerala  using  dinghies  that  were  tied  together  to  form  a  makeshift  platform.  This  was  also  the  time  when  untouchable  women  were  prohibited  from  covering  the  top  portion  of  their  bodies.  As  part  of  the  self‐respect  movement,  he  brought  together  thousands  of  women  labourers  for  a  meeting  and  incited  them  to  break  the  stone  bead  chains  covering  their  reasts  and  demand  the  right  to  wear  blouses  in  par  with  the  custom  followed  only  by  the  upper  caste  women  at  that  time.  He  successfully  led  many  such  self‐respect  movements  through  Sadhu  Jana  Paripalana  Sangham.

He  withstood  all  the  punishments  (both  physical  and  mental)  meted  out  to  him  by  the  Hindu  upper  castes  for  his  involvement  in  these  social  movements.  The  result  is,  more  equitable  educational  opportunities  that  we  are  witnessing  today.  During  the  freedom  movement,  Mahatma  Gandhi  met  Ayyankali  in  Venganur  village  and  reportedly  commended  him  by  saying:  “We  are  contemporaries  in  age.  I  am  fighting  for  freedom  and  so  are  you.”  Little  later  when  Ayyankali  was  ill,  Gandhi  went  to  see  him  and  asked  him  what  he  wished  (to  have  achieved)  the  most  in  his  life.  Ayyankali  responded  by  saying  “Please  extend  support  to  Ambedkar  who,  like  you  is  fighting  for  the  welfare  of  the  untouchables.”  Gandhi  asked  him  what  else  he  wanted.  Ayyankali  said  that  he  would  like  educational  opportunities  for  people  of  his  community  and  that  before  he  dies,  he  would  like  to  see  at  least  12  graduates.  Responding  to  his  wish,  the

Govt.  of  Tranvencore  built  hostels  for  Harijan  students.  All  the  leading  politicians  including  the  heads  of  the  princely  states  unanimously  decided  to  make  him  a  member  of  the  legislaive  assembly.

We  must  publicize  the  struggles  for  educational  rights  undertaken  by  Ayyankali  on  behalf  of  the  untouchables.  The  children  of  the  untouchables  should  learn  about  Ayyankali  and  the  methods  he  used  in  those  struggles.  His  work  should  not  remain  outside  history  or  even  be  confined  to  some  minor  histories.  The  lessons  from  that  history  must  inspire  our  current  struggles  for  equality  and  quality  education  for  all.  Only  through  education  can  one  become  leaders.

Even  today  we  have  scores  of  children  who  are  unable  to  go  to  school;  who  are  forced  to  become  child  labourers.  We  need  to  demand  quality  education  to  everyone  irrespective  of  the  class  and  caste.  The  limited  education  in  Telugu  medium  is  only  making  the  youth  from  marginalized  sections  to  become  labourers  or  people  fit  oly  to  carry  party  flags  during  political  meetings.  Modern  schools  and  English  medium  education  is  still  an  unattainable  dream  for  the  untouchables.  Thanks  to  the  struggles  organized  by  Dalit  Bahujan  leaders  and  writers,  the  Government  has  only  recently  introduced  English  medium  in  6500  Government  schools  from  6th class  to  Intermediate  level  in  .P.  Let  us  welcome  that  move.  In  fact,  we  need  to  demand  for  introduction  of  English  right  from  1st standard  in  government  schools.

New  arrivals  in  English  under  different  subject  headings

Dalit  Studies-Caste-Minorities

Dalit  women  speakout:  violence  against  dalit  women  in  India/  Aloysius  S.J.  Irudayam.  –  New  Delhi:  NCDHR,  2006.

The  scheduled  castes  in  India/  Sarajit  Kumar  Chatterjee  (four  volumes).  –  New  Delhi:  Gyan  Publishing  House,  2008.

Muslim  communities  of  South  Asia:  culture,  society  and  power/  edited  by  T.N.Madan.  –  3rd enlarged  edition.  –  New  Delhi:  Manohar,  2001.

The  meaning  of  the  Ambedkarite  conversion  to  Buddhism  and  other  essays/  K.N.Kadam.  –  Mumbai:  Popular  Prakashan,  1997.

Breaking  the  monolith:  essays,  articles  and  columns  on  Islam,  India,  terror  and  other  things  that  annoy  me/  Ziauddin  Sardar.  –  Gurgaon:  Imprint  one,  2008.

Law-Justice- Human  Rights

Speaking  in  god’s  name:  Islamic  law,  authority  and  women/  Khaled  Abu  El  Fadl.  –  Reprint.  ‐  Oxford:  One  World,  2008.

Narrative,  violence  and  the  law:  the  essays  of  Robert  Cover/  edited  by  Martha  Minow;  Michael  Ryan  and  Austin  Sarat.  –  Ann  Arbor:  The  University  of  Michigan  Press,  1995.

The  province  of  jurisprudence  determined/  John  Austin.  –  Cambridge:  Cambridge  University  Press,  1995.

An  introduction  to  the  philosophy  of  law/  Roscoe  Pound.  –  New  Haven:  Yale  University  Press,  1922.

Challenging  the  rules  of  law:  colonialism,  criminology  and  human  rights  in  India/  edited  by  Kalpana  Kannabiran;  Ranbir  Singh.  –  New  Delhi:  Sage  Publications,  2008.

Law’s  empire/  Ronald  Dworkin.  –  Cambridge:  The  Belknap  press  of  Harvard  University  Press,  1986.

Law,  violence  and  the  philosophy  of  justice/  edited  by  Austin  Sarat.  –  Princeton:  Princeton  University  Press,  2002.

The  principles  of  morals  and  legislation/  Jeremy  Bentham.  –  New  York:  Prometheus  Books,  1988.

A  life  of  H.L.A.  Hart:  the  nightmare  and  the  noble  dream/  Nicola  Lacey.  –  Oxford:  OUP,  2004.

Towards  legal  literacy:  an  introduction  to  law  in  India/  edited  by  Kamala  Sankaran;  Ujjwal  Kumar  Singh.  –  New  Delhi:  OUP,  2008.

Women,  madness  and  the  law:  a  feminist  reader/  edited  by  Wendy  Chan;  Dorothy  E  Chunn,  Robert  Menzies.  –  London:  Glasshouse  press,  2005.

Literature

A  thousand  splendid  suns/  Khaled  Hosseini.  –  New  York:  Riverhead  books,  2007.

Black  skin,  white  masks/  Frantz  Fanon.  –  New  York:  Grove  Press,  2007.

Vanman:  Vendetta/  Bama.  –  New  Delhi:  OUP,  2008.

A  wilderness  of  possibilities:  Urdu  studies  in  transnational  perspective/  edited  by  Kathryn  Hansen  and  David  Lelyveld.  –  New  Delhi:  OUP,  2005.

Behind  the  veil:  representation  of  Muslim  woman  in  Indian  writings  in  English  1950‐2000/  edited  by  A.R.Kidwai.  –  New  Delhi:  Manohar,  2006.

Literary  Criticism-Theory

Elusive  terrain:  culture  and  literary  memory/  Meenakshi  Mukherjee.  –  New  Delhi:  OUP,  2008.

Limiting  secularism:  the  ethics  of  coexistence  in  Indian  literature  and  film/  Priya  Kumar.  –  Ranikhet:  Permanent  Black,  2008.

Religion

Beyond  belief:  Islamic  excursions  among  the  converted  peoples/  V.S.  Naipul.  –  London:  Abacus,  1999.

Imperialism

Religion  versus  empire?:  British  protestant  missionaries  and  overseas  expansion,  1700‐1914/  Andrew  Porter.  –  Manchester:  Manchester  University  Press,  2004.

Politics-Social  Sciences

Kant:  Political  writings/  Kant;  edited  by  H.S.  Reiss.  –  2nd enlarged  edition.  –  Cambridge:  Cambridge  University  Press,  1991.

Liberalism  and  empire:  India  in  British  liberal  thought/  Uday  Singh  Mehta.  –  New  Delhi:  OUP,  1999.

Dr.  Babasaheb  Ambedkar  and  the  significance  of  his  movement:  a  chronology/  edited  by  K.N.Kadam.  –  Reprint.  –  Bombay:  Popular  Prakashan,  1993.

Anthropology

The  ethnographer’s  eye:  ways  of  seeing  in  modern  anthropology/  Anna  Grimshaw.  –  Cambridge:  Cambridge  University  Press,  2001.

Political  Anthropology

Sovereign  bodies:  citizens,  migrants  and  states  in  the  postcolonial  world/  edited  by  Thomas  Hansen  and  Finn  Stepputat.  –  Princeton:  Princeton  University  Press,  2005.

Secularism

A  secular  age/  Charles  Taylor.  –  Cambridge:  Cambridge  University  Press,  2007.

Gender  studies-Feminism

Hermeneutics  and  honor:  negotiating  female  “public”  space  in  Islamicate  societies/  edited  by  Asma  Afsaruddin.  –  Cambridge:  Cambridge  University  Press,  1999.

Marxism

The  German  ideology  including  theses  on  Feuerbach  and  the  introduction  to  the  critique  of  political  economy/  Karl  Marx  with  Friedrich  Engels.  –  New  York:  Promotheus  Books,  1998.

Terrorism

Understanding  terrorism  in  South  Asia:  beyond  statist  discourses/  edited  by  Imtiaz  Ahmed.  –  New  Delhi:  Manohar,  2006.

New  arrivals  in  Telugu  under  different  subject  headings

Kavithvam

Maakoddee  maala  dorathanamoo...dandora  geethaalu/  Sudayya

Mallee  mallee  pudathaa/  Vasa  Prabhavathi.‐ Hyderabad:  Vasa  prachuranalu,2002.

Ruthu  ghosha:  padya  kaavyam  &  Mande  suryudu:  vachana  kavithaa  samputi/  Sathyaki  G.ed.‐ Houston:  Kavitha  publications,  2008.

Vihwala  &  mabbullo  darbaaru/  Sathyaki  G.ed.‐Gudur:  Kesareddy  Rangareddy,  2008.

Kulam‐ Minority‐ B.C.Kulaalu

Minority  B.C.kulaalu:  saamaajika‐ aarthika‐ raajakeeya  sthithigathulu/Ko.Pra

Aadi  vaaseela  apoorvaa  vijayagaatha:  girijana  hakkulanu  punaruddharinchina  Supreme  Court  charithraathmaka  theerpu/  Samatha.‐ Andhra  Pradesh:  Samatha,  2003.

Pramukhulu

Saahithee  sumaalu:  Bhaaratheeya  rachaethala  parichayaalu/  Nalimela  Bhaskar.‐ Sirisilla:  Nayanam  prachuranalu.

Bhasha‐ Rajakeeyaalu

Dalitha  bahujanulaku  Telugu  agra  kulaalaku  English  chaduvaa?!/  Ilaiah  Kancha.‐Hyderabad:  Hyderabad  Book  Trust,2006.

Baanam:  Telangana  bhaashaa  vyaasaalu/  ed.by  Bhaskar  Nalimela   &  Gouri  sankar  Juluru.

Saahithyam

Brahma  samaaja  saahithyam:  oka  pariseelana/  Kanuparthi  Vijaya  lakshmi.

Jyothirao  Phule:  sankshiptha  rachanalu/  Harathi  Vageesan.‐ Hyderabad:  Hyderabad  Book  Trust,2006.

Yaaminee  vilaasam:  saahithee  pada  chithraavali/  Yamini  Saraswathi.‐ Nandyala:  Surana  Saraswatha  Sangham,1992.

Maadigodu/  Naagappa  gaari  Sunder  raju

Noorella  kanyaasulkam  (1892‐1992)/  Saahithee  saamskruthika  samstha.‐ Vijayanagaram:  Saahithee  Samskruthika  samstha,2008.

Irusu:  Telangana  saahithya  vyaasaalu/  Prathap  reddy,  Kasula.‐ Miryalaguda:  Matti  mudranalu,  2008.

Navalaa  manjari  Vol.1  &2/  Malathi  Chandur.‐ Vijayawada:  Quality  publishers,  2008.

Vyaasaalu

Communisamaa?  Kosthaa  vaadamaa?:  C.P.M.Telangana  vyathireka  vaikharipai  vyaasaalu/ed.by  Narayana  Reddy  Sunki  reddy  ,  Subhadra  Joopaka,  Deshpande  Sridhar,Srinivas  Sangisetti  &  Prathap  reddy  Kasula  .‐ Hyderabad:  Telangana  Vidyavanthula  Vedika,  2008.

Thaajaa  kalam/  Srinivas  rao  Kommineni.‐Hyderabad:  I‐DAR,  2006.

Navalalu

Munemma/  Kesavareddy.‐ Hyderabad:  Hyderabad  Book  Trust,2008.

Pattaabhi:  oka  naati  ujwala  kamma  saamraajyam  pai  tholi  praamaanika  navala/  Sivaprasad  Mudigonda

Karuna  &  daagudu  moothalu/  Naveen  Ampasayya.‐ Warangal:  Prathyusha  Prachuranalu,2008.

Kolimantukunnadi,  ooru  &  agni  kanam:  moodu  navalalu  (1978‐1982)/  Vara  vara  rao.‐ Hyderabad:  Perspectives,  2008.

Telangana

Thiraga  badda  Telangana:  doralanu  dinchaam..Nizam  nu  koolchaam/  Thirumali  Inukonda  .‐ Hyderabad:  Hyderabad  Book  trust,

Telangana  raashtram:  mahila‐ dalitha‐ bahujana‐ minority  asthithvaalu/  M.Rathnamala.‐ Hyderabad:  Nuthana  prachuranalu,  2008.

Ooregimpu:  Telangana  sangathulu/  K.Vimala.‐ Hyderabad:  Jaada  publications,2006.

Telangana  mucchata/M.Kodanda  ram.‐ Hyderabad:Ramayya  Vidya  peetam,  2008.

Udyamaalu‐ Andhra  Pradesh

Mahatthara  Sreekaakula  poraatam(chaarithraka  pariseelana)/  Sivarami  reddy.‐ Chaganti  Bhaskar  rao  prachuranalu,  2006.

Raajakeeyalu

Andhra  Pradesh  lo  sthaanika  samsthala  ennikalu‐ 2001(  mandalaalu,  Z.P.T.C  lu,  graama  panchaayatheelu)

Sthreelu‐ Aarogyam

Ammaye  amma  ammamma:  aarogya  kosam/  Gayathri  devi.‐ Mumbai:  Aarogyapeetam,  2007.

Vikalaangulaina  sthreelu:  aarogya  samrakshana/  Maxwell  Jane,  Wats  beller  Julia  &  David  Darlina  tr.by  Rani

Contents of Journals

AGENDA

ISSUE  13  2008

Against  Exclusion:  The  roots  of  social  exclusion  abd  battles  against  it

Introduction:  one  person,  one  value  by  Anosh  Malekar

Towards  inclusion  and  equity  by  Prakash  Louis

Garbage  as  a  metaphor  by  Nityanand  Jayaraman,  photographs  by  Sudharak  olwe

1,001  battles:  converting  dalit  numbers  into  dalit  strength  by  Padmalatha  Ravi

Caste  is  the  cruelest  exclusion  by  Gail  Omvedt

Dalit  exclusion:  the  empirical  evidence  by  Sukhadeo  Thorat

Caste  in  the  west  by  Nikki  Van  Der  Gaag

Giving  adivasis  a  voice  by  G  N  Devy

Queer  azadi  by  Sidharth  Narrain

Tamil  Nadu  pioneers  transgender  inclusion  by  Anupama  Sekhar

The  silence  of  same  sex  desiring  women  by  Ponni  Arasu

No  white  for  these  widows  by  Freny  Manecksha

Hukumnama  against  female  foeticide  by  Anosh  Malekar

Sex  workers  as  economic  agents  by  Manjima  Bhattachariya

Exclusions  of  Muslims  by  J  S  Bandukwala

Persons  with  disability  may  apply  by  Monideepa  Sahu

Discrimination  is  built  into  our  legislation  by  Alok  Prakash  Putul

Battling  the  triple  burden  of  poverty,  religion  and  gender  by  Anosh  Malekar

The  fallacy  of  equality  by  Oishik  Sircar

ASIAN  JOURNAL  OF  WOMEN’S  STUDIES

VOL.  14,  NO.  3,  2008

ARTICLES

Affirmation,  pain  and  empowerment

Rosi  Braidotti

Politics  of  meaning:  care  work  and  migrant  women

Huh  Ra‐Keum

How  ideas  migrate:  reflections  from  an  international  comparative  project

Marilyn  Porter  &  Krist  Poerwandari

From  ideal  women  to  women’s  Ideal:  evolution  the  female  image  in  Chinese  feature  films,  149‐2000

Chen  Yanru

BOOK  REVIEW

Sreelekha  Nair, Women  workers  and  globalization:  emergent  contradictions  in  India,  Indrani  Mazumdar,  Kolkata:  Stree,  2007.

THE  BOOK  REVIEW

VOL.XXXII,  NUMBER  10,  OCTOBER  2008

South  Asian  Special‐ XII

Rajan  Gurukkal A  history  of  ancient  and  early  medieval  India:  from  the  Stone  Age  to  the  12th century  by  Upinder  Singh

Kumkum  Roy Discovering  the  Vedas:  origins,  Myths,  mantras,  rituals,  insights  by  Frits  Staal

Meena  Bhargava Indi‐Persian  travels  in  the  age  of  discoveries,  1400‐1800  by  Muzaffar  Alam  and  Sanjay  Subrahmanyam

Radhika  Chaddha Makers  of  Islamic  civilization:  the  Battula  by  L.P.  Harvey

Kanakalata  Mukund Merchants,  traders,  entrepreneurs;  Indian  business  in  the  colonial  era  by   Claude  Markovits

A.  Gangatharan surveying  and  mapping  in  colonial  Sri  Lanka  by  Ian  J.  Barrow

P.K.Datta Spoils  of  partition:  Bengal  and  India,  1947‐1967  by  Joya  Chatterji

Pippa  Virdee The  long  partition  and  the  making  of  modern  South  Asia:  refugees,  boundaries,  histories  by  Vazira  Fazila‐Yacoobali  Zamindar;

Spirals  of  contention:  why  India  was  partitioned  in  1947  by  Satish  Saberwal

Michael  H.  Fisher Partisans  of  Allah:  Jihad  in  South  Asia  by Ayesha  Jalal

Amiya  P.Sen Colonialism,  modernity  and  religious  identities:  religious  reforms  movements  in  South  Asia  edited  by  Gwilym  Beckerlegge

J.Devika Women  and  social  reform  in  moern  India  Vol.1  edited  by  Sumit  Sarkar  and  Tanika  Sarkar

Kalpana  Kannabiran towards  gender  history:  images,  identities  and  roles  of  North  Indian  Women  with  special  reference  to  Punjab  by  Kamlesh  Mohan

Padmini  Swaminathan Exposing  the  myths  of  Muslim  fertility:  gender  and  religion  in  a  resettlement  colony  of  Delhi  by  Sabiha  Hussain

Neetha  N. Marriage,  migration  and  gender:  women  and  migration  in  Asia,  volume  5  edited  by  Rajni  Palriwala  and  Patricia  Oberoi

Rekha  Pappu Feminisms  in  development:  contradictions,  contestations  &  challenges  edited  by  Andrea  Cornwall,  Elizabeth  Harrison  &  Ann  Whitehead

Maithreyi  Krishnaraj Global  empowerment  of  Women:  responses  to  globalization  and  politicized  religions  edited  by  Carolyn  M.  Elliott

Praveen  Jha Making  globalization  work:  the  next  step  to  global  justice  by  Joseph  Stiglitz

D.N.Reddy India’s  economic  transition:  the  politics  of  reforms  edited  by  Rahul  Mukherji

I.N.Mukherji Changing  perceptions,  altered  reality:  Pakistan’s  economy  under  Musharraf,  1999‐2006  by  Shahid  Javed  Burki; Initiating  devolution  for  service  delivery  in  Pakistan:  ignoring  the  power  structure  by  Shahrukh  Rafi  Khan,  Foqia  Sadiq  Khan  and  Aasim  Sajjad  Akhtar

Shakti  Kak representing  children:  power,  policy  and  the  discourse  on  child  labour  in  the  football  manufacturing  industry  of  Pakistan  by  Ali  Khan

Harini  Nagendra Knowledge  systems  and  national  resources:  management,  policy  and  institutions  in  Nepal  edited  by  Hemant  R.  Ojha,  Netra  P.  Timsina,  Ram  B.  Chhetri  and  Krishna  P.  Paudel

Navroz  Dubash Climate  change:  An  Indian  perspective  by  Sushil  Kumar  Dash

V.S  Vyas Governance  of  water:  institutional  alternative  and  political  economy  edited  Vishwa  Ballabh

K.C.  Suri Explaining  Indian  Democracy:  a  fifty‐year  perspective,  1956‐2006;  Volume  1:  The  realm  of  Ideas:  Inquiry  and  theory;  Volume  II:  The  realm  of  institutions:  state  formation  and  institutional  change;  VolumeIII:  The  realm  of  the  public  sphere:  identity  and  policy  by  Lloyd  I.  Rudolph  and  Susanne  Hoeber  Rudolph

Amit  Prakash State  of  democracy  in  South  Asia:  A  report;  Local  democracy  in  South  Asia:  micro  process  of  democratization  in  Nepal  and  its  neighbours  edited  by  David  N.  Gellner  and  Krishna  Hachhethu

Ajay  Darshan  Behera Electoral  processes  and  governance  in  South  Asia  edited  by  Dushyantha  Mendis

Ashwini  K.Ray The  history  of  human  rights:  from  ancient  times  in  the  globalization  era  by  Micheline  R.  Ishay; Human  rights  and  humanitarian  law:  developments  in  Indian  and  international  law  by  South  Asia  Human  Rights  Documentation  Centre

David  M.  Malone The  second  world:  empires  and  influence  in  the  new  global  order  by  Parag  Khanna

V.R.Raghavan US  relations  with  Afghanistan  and  Pakistan:  the  imperial  dimension  by  Hafeez  Malik

Lalima  Verma Asian  security  dynamics:  US,  Japan  and  the  rising  powers  edited  by  V.R.  Raghavan

Rear  Admiral Maritime  security  in  the  Indian  Ocean  Region:  critical  issues  in

Raja  Menon debate  edited  by  V.R.Raghavan  and  Lawrence  Prabhakar

K.Subrahmanyam Armed  conflicts  in  South  Asia  2008:  growing  violence  edited  by  D.Subra  Chandran  and  P.R.  Chari

P.R.Chari Crossed  swords:  Pakistan,  its  army  and  the  wars  within  by  Shuja  Nawaz

S.Kalyanaraman Fighting  lika  a  guerrilla:  The  Indian  Army  and  counterinsurgency  by  Rajesh  Rajagopalan

T.C.A.  Rangachari Architect  of  global  Jihad:  the  life  of  al‐Qaida  stategist  Abu  Mus’ab  Al‐Suri  by  Brynjar  Lia

I.P.Khosla The  last  colony:  Muzaffarabad‐Gilgit‐Baltistan  edited  by  P.Stobdan  and  D.  Suba  Chandran

Anuradha  M.  Chenoy Women  in  peace  politics  by  Paula  Banerjee

Swarna  Rajagopalan Constellations  of  Violence:  feminist  interventions  in  South  Asia  edited  by  Radhika  Coomaraswamy  and  Nimanthi  Perera‐Rajasingham

Monica  Juneja The  triumph  of  modernism:  India’s  artists  and  the  Avant‐garde,  1922‐1947  by  Partha  Mitter

Sabina  Gadihoke Umrao  Singh  Sher‐gil:  his  misery  and  his  manuscript  edited  by  Vivan  Sundaram  and  Devika  Daule‐Singh

A.G.K.Menon Beathless  in  Bombay  by  Murzban  F.  Shroff;

Delhi  metropolitan:  the  making  of  an  unlikely  city  by  Ranjana  Sengupta

Narayani  Gupta Karachi  during  the  British  era:  two  historiesof  a  modern  city  introduction  by  Roland  DeSouza; The  historical  quarters  of  Karachi  by  Yasmin  Cheema

Ebba  Koch Agra:  The  architectural  heritage  by  Lucy  Peck

Janaki  Nair Beantown,  boomtown:  Bangalore  in  the  world  of  words  by  Jayanth  Kodkani  and  R.  Edwin  Sudhir

Madhuja  Mukherjee Speaking  havoc,  social  suffering  &  South  Asian  narratives  by  Ramu  Nagappan

Shohini  Ghosh Filming  the  line  of  control:  The  Indo‐Pak  relationship  through  the  cinematic  lens  edited  by  Meenakshi  Bharat  and  Nirmal  Kumar

Prema  Chari Sanctuary!  By  Hema  Ramakrishna

Gillian  Wright Fireflies  in  the  mist  by  Qurratulain  Hyder

Gagan  Gill Memory’s  daughter  (A  novel)  by  Krishna  Sobti; To  hell  with  you,  Mitro  (A  Novel)  by  Krishna  Sobti

Sumanyu  Satpathy Ramnabami‐Natak:  the  story  of  Ram  and  Nabami  by  Gunabhiram  Barua

Chinmay  Chakrabarty Freedom’s  Ransom  by  Prafulla  Roy

Radha  Chakravarty Neither  night  nor  day:  13  stories  by  women  writers  from  Pakistan  edited  by  Rakshanda  Jalil

Baran  Rehman The  penitence  of  Nasooh  by  Nazir  Ahmad  Dehlavi;

The  story  of  Maulvi  Nazir  ahmad  in  his  words  and  mine  by  Mirza  Farhatullah  Baig

Rakshanda  Jalil Coming  back  home:  selected  articles,  editorial  and  interviews  of  Faiz  Ahmed  Faiz  compiled  by  Sheema Majeed. Introduction  by  Khalid  Hasan

Shobhana  Bhattacharji A  journey  interrupted:  being  Indian  in  Pakistan  by  Farzana  Versey

Srikanth  Kondapalli Smoke  and  mirrors:  an  experience  of  China  by  Pallavi  Aiyar

Pamela  Philipose Stop  press:  a  life  in  Journalism  by  Inam  Aziz;  Themes  and  variations  by  Amalendu  Das  Gupta; The  boxwallah  and  the  middleman  by  Raj  Chatterjee

MEDICO  FRIEND  CIRCLE  BULLETIN

NO.330  AUGUST‐SEPTEMBER  2008

“We  have  planted  a  sapling  of  a  Banyan  tree”

Ravindra  R.P.

Commercialization  of  surrogacy  in  the  Indian  context

N.B.  Sarojini  et  al

The  hunger  bazaar

Radha  Holla  &  Lakshmi  Menon

Urban  initiatives  for  a  fossil  fuel  free  society

T.  Vijayendra

Concept  note  about  dabate  on  infection  control

Pankaj  Shah,  et  al

Dharampal,  1924‐2006

M.R.Rajagopalan

Guardian  of  our  secret  hometowns

Testing  untested  foreign  drugs

I’m  fine  Thank  you

Kamala  Jaya  Rao

REPRODUCTIVE  HEALTH  MATTERS

VOL.  16  NO.31  SUPPLEMENT  MAY  2008

INTRODUCTION

Second  trimester  abortion:  Women’s  health  and  public  policy

Rodica  Comendant,  Mage  Berer

THE  LAW  AND  SAFETY  OF  SECOND  TRIMESTER  ABORTION

A  critical  appraisal  of  laws  on  second  trimester  abortion

Marge  Berer

Who  is  excluded  when  abortion  access  is  restricted  to  twelve  weeks?  Evidence  from  Maputo  Mozambique

Momade  Bay  Usta,  Ellen  MH  Mitchell,  Haillemcichael  Gebreselassie,  Eunice  Brookman‐Amissah,  Amata  Kwizera

WOMEN’S  PERSPECTIVES

Reasons  for  second  trimester  abortions  in  England  and  Wales

Roger  Ingham,  Ellie  Lee,  Steve  Joanne  Clements,  Nicloe  Stone

Factors  influencing  the  percentage  of  second  trimester  abortions  in  the  Netherlands

Olga  Loeber,  Cecile  Wijsen

Second  trimester  abortions  in  India

Suchitra  S  Dalvie

Late‐term  abortion  for  fetal  anomaly:  Vietnamese  women’s  experiences

Tine  Gammetoft,  Tran  Minh  Hang,  Nguyen  Thi  Nguyen  Thi  Thuy  Hanh

Termination  of  pregnancy  for  fetal  abnormality:  the  perspective  of  a  parent  support  organization

Jane  Fisher

PROVIDERS’  PERSPECTIVES

Why  I  do  abortions

Garson  Romalis

A  week  in  the  life  of  an  abortion  doctor,  Western  Cape  Province,  South  Africa

Marijke  Alblas

Second  trimester  abortion  provision:  breaking  the  silence  and  changing  the  discourse

Lisa  H  Harris

Decision‐making  after  ultrasound  diagnosis  of  fetal  abnormality

Hilmar  H  Bijma,  Agnes  Van  der  Heide,  Hajo  IJ  Wildschut

POLICY,  POLITICS  AND  VALUES

Maintaining  access  to  safe  abortion  and  reducing  sex  ratio  imbalances  in  Asia

Bela  Ganatra

Implications  of  the  federal  abortion  ban  for  women’s  health  in  the  United  States

Tracy  A  Weitz,  Susan  Yanow

Clarifying  values  and  transforming  attitudes  to  improve  access  to  second  trimester  abortion

Katherine  L  Turner,  Alyson  G  Hyman,  Mosotho  C  Gabriel

Fetal  pain:  do  we  know  enough  to  do  the  right  thing?

Stuart  WG  Derbyshire

SERVICE  DELIVERY:  FROM  UNSAFE  TO  SAFE  IN  THE  SECOND  TRIMESTER

Applying  the  WHO  strategic  approach  to  strengthen  first  and  second  trimester  abortion  services  in  Mongolia

Bazarrachoa  Tsogt,  Khisgee  Seded,  Brooke  R  Johnson,  and  the  strategic  Assessment  team

Establishing  second  trimester  abortion  services:  experiences  in  Nepal,  Viet  Nam  and  South  Africa

Alyson  G  Hyman,  Traci  L  Baird,  Indira  Basnett

Second  trimester  abortion  in  Viet  Nam:  changing  to  recommended  methods  and  improving  service  delivery

Tuyet  Hoang  TD,  thuy  Phan,  trang  Huynh  NK

CURRENTLY  RECOMMENDED  METHODS:  EVIDENCE  AND  ETHICS

Surgical  abortion  in  the  second  trimester

Patricia  A  Lohr

Second  trimester  medical  abortion  with  mifepristone‐misoprostol  and  misoprostol  alone:  a  review  of  methods  and  management

Kristina  Gemzell‐Danielsson,  Sujata  Lalitkumar

Complications  after  second  trimester  surgical  and  medical  abortion

Daniel  Grossman,  Kelly  Blanchard,  Paul  Blumenthol

The  choice  of  second  trimester  abortion  method:  evolution,  evidence  and  ethics

David  A  Grimes

METHODS  THAT  SHOULD  GO  OUT  OF  USE

Misoprostol  preferable  to  ethacridine  lactate  for  abortions  at  13‐20  weeks  of  pregnancy:  Cuban  experience

Alejandro  Velazco  Boza,  Rodolfo  Gomez  Ponce  de  Leon,  Luis  Salas  Castillo,  Dania  Rebeca  Yi  Marino,  Ellen  MH  Mitchell

An  historical  overview  of  second  trimester  abortion  methods

Marc  Bygdeman,  Kristina  gemzell‐Danielsson

RECOMMENDATIONS

International  Conference  on  Second  trimester  Abortion,  29‐31  March  2007.

SAMYUKTA:  A  JOURNAL  OF  WOMEN’S  STUDIES

VOL.VII,  NO.  2,  JULY  2007

Selected  poems  from  muturai  and  nalvali

Thomas  H.  Pruiksma

Thiruppavai  of  aandaal:  the  song  of  the  maidens

Shobha  Ramasamy

Researching  the  icons:  women  seers  in  the  rig  Veda

Snehi  Chauhan

Mirabai  and  divine  romanticism

Shubha  Narayan

Rituals  and  the  Namboothiri  women

Ladha  Bharathan

Morning  &  other  poems

Srividya  Sivakumar

The  offering

Nalini  Bakel

Poems

Mani  Rao

Tsunami  New  Year  27  December  2004  to  2  January  2005:  Prologue

Susan  Visvanathan

The  journey

P.Sreekala

Dharma:  after  Kurukshetra

Susan  Oommen

Stanley

Atima  Srivastava

Captain  Lakshmi  Sahgal:  working  towards  a  radical  transformation  of  society

Veena  Pooncha

My  colonial  education

Maria  N.  NG

Gloria  Anzaldua:  from  a  room  of  one’s  own  to  borderlands/  LA  Frontera

Roshan  Thomas

Book  Reviews

SEMINAR:  THE  MONTHLY  SYMPOSIUM

NO.590  OCTOBER  2008

Unfinished  Agendas  2:  a  symposium  on  some  continuing  concerns  over  five  decades

A  letter  from  seminar

Uneasy  co‐existence

Jagdish  N.  Bhagwati

The  public  and  the  private

Suman  Bery

Films  and  films:  a  letter

Chetan  Anand

What’s  wrong  with  our  movies?

Rajeev  Masand

Multilingual  aspect

S.  Ehtesham  Husain

Multilinguality  for  India

Rama  Kant  Agnihotri

A  question  of  priorities

I.P.  Desai,  R.F.  Kothari  and  I.S.  Gulati

Obstacles  to  a  new  revolution

Pratap  Bhanu  Mehta

Deep  roots

J.B.  Kriplani

The  necessity  of  corruption

Shiv  Vishwanathan

BOOKS

Reviewed  by  Kailash  K.K.,  Sambit  Mallick,  Rita  Manchanda  and  Susan  Visvanathan

COMMENT

The  war  on  terror  and  the  idea  of  Pakhtoonistan

Saeed  Naqvi

BACKPAGE

Published  Stories,  articles,  Book  reviews  of  Anveshi  members

Baaitalam/  Gogu  Shyamala

Pranahita.org,  October  2008.

Seerelu  simpi  raikalu  gunji…./  Joopaka  Subadra

Bhumika,  November  2008.

Feminisms  in  development:  contradictions,  contestations  &  challenges  edited  by  Andrea  Cornwall,  Elizabeth  Harrison  &  Ann  Whitehead/ Rekha  Pappu,

The  Book  Review,Oct. 2008